In the Amish community of Caroline Creek, a boy disappears. The elders turn a blind eye, leaving only Maria, the stubborn sister, to defend her brother. Maria teams up with an English private investigator. They uncover mob involvement, a generations-old ongoing crime, and what's worse, participation from someone inside the community.
When the bishop from the Amish community of Caroline Creek disappears, the church becomes vulnerable. Someone, an invisible force, is manipulating them, and forcing them to conspire against each other. Members are quick to point fingers at everyone but themselves. Then, one fateful night, they are pushed too far and the community turns to violence.